Mutation triage: v1.2.0 candidate¶
This is an adjudication of recorded experiments, not a claim that the original program contains every injected defect. A surviving mutation proves that its executed tests did not distinguish that changed program; a timeout proves neither survival nor semantic correctness. No production source was edited for this review.
Frozen scope and accounting¶
The adjudicated sample records 135 completed mutants: 80 caught, 43 missed, 7 unviable and 5 timeouts, selected by round-robin shard 1/40 across eight crates. Initial adapter/proxy baselines failed before any mutant ran; their completed retry snapshots supersede those two initial rows only. The original source manifest and retry source manifest identify the frozen sources. The original enumerated inventory was 5,226 possible mutations; the full space was not executed. The latest per-crate inventories in the adjudicated mixed-snapshot rows sum to 5,241; this is inventory drift between snapshots, not additional executed coverage. These samples do not establish a population mutation score.
The later directed critical run, with its separate source manifest, records 59 experiments: 30 caught and 29 missed, with no recorded timeout/unviable outcome. Its per-crate selected counts are core 30, HDC 13, bus 10 and codec 6. Twelve full recorded names also occur in the original sample; three directed misses also occur among the original misses. Line movement creates additional semantic overlap (for example frame-fit line 456 → 462). Do not add 135+59, caught totals, or inventories to report unique tested mutations. No deduplicated cross-snapshot coverage total is asserted here.
Stable recorded names below include path, frozen location, function and mutation. Guard snippets/follow-ups identify semantic intent when lines move. Source links point to the current function location; manifests/outcomes, rather than current line numbers, establish the experiment's provenance. Subsequent source/tests may differ. A later ordinary test addition is never retroactively counted as CaughtMutant.
Classification: G = meaningful test/oracle gap for an observable contract or safety boundary; P = source-proven returned-value equivalence with a possible cost difference; N = no defect/equivalence established under the documented heuristic/fixture contract; T = recorded timeout requiring bounded direct follow-up. G is not an allegation of a defect in unmutated production source. Two P classifications below are narrowly scoped; no blanket equivalence waiver is given to other survivors.
All 43 sampled survivors and five timeouts¶
| ID | Frozen outcome / full semantic name | Class | Source proof or counterevidence | Follow-up / later evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S01 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:77:9: replace CasStore::unique_chunk_count -> usize with 0 (log) |
G | Public deduplication count can return zero after insertion. source | Current integrity_v120 asserts one unique chunk before/after duplicate insertion; later test, not a rerun outcome. |
| S02 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:565:21: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts (log) |
G | Line-index byte_offset guard can be weakened independently of chunk identity/length. source | Current integrity_v120 independently corrupts all five line-index fields; frozen directed run already catches some byte guards, not every later test. |
| S03 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/chunker.rs:111:23: replace < with > in chunk_bytes (log) |
G | Disables the relaxed-mask phase when pos is below limit; reconstruction can still pass with different boundaries. source | Add a deterministic nontrivial input that reaches phase 2 and assert independently calculated CDC boundaries, not only round-trip/min/max. |
| S04 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:324:22: replace match guard *n_agent == agent && n_role == role && *n_raw == raw_artifact with false in MerkleContextDag::find_turn (log) |
G | Deletes the uncached serde-restored find_turn fallback match. source | Directed run catches this semantic mutant; current integrity_v120 exercises fallback identity. Preserve sampled Missed outcome. |
| S05 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:976:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors (log) |
G | Turn verification combines digest/prefix/map-ID checks; one false conjunct can hide another mismatch. source | Current integrity_v120 separately tampers data and jointly forges map/internal IDs; remutate each independent guard to confirm. |
| S06 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1112:25: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors (log) |
G | L3 epoch verification combines root/prefix/map-ID/frame checks. source | Current integrity_v120 tampers epoch root and map/internal IDs; remutate each condition without relying on a simultaneous frame mismatch. |
| S07 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-core/src/epoch.rs:456:21: replace <= with > in CacheEpochController::assemble_window (log) |
G | Whole-frame fit selection is reversed; earlier fixtures did not observe missing/oversized frames. source | Directed run catches the shifted frame-fit mutant (line 462); do not identify it by line number alone or revise frozen result. |
| S08 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/ahtl.rs:207:28: replace && with \|\| in escape_clause_field (log) |
P | Only broadens needs-escaping detection in the fast-return predicate; the unchanged escaping loop still decides what to escape. source | Source proof: A&&B implies A||B, so fast return is taken for a subset of previously safe strings. Output is unchanged; extra allocation/scan is observable only as cost. |
| S09 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/ahtl.rs:734:31: replace \|\| with && in AhtlWirePacketV1::parse (log) |
G | Hex length and alphabet are separate malformed-input cases; && can accept one bad property. source | Directed parser run catches this exact mutant; current codec_v120 independently tests alphabet and length. |
| S10 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:157:19: replace + with * in SecretRedactor::sensitive_continuation (log) |
G | Changes the UTF-8-aware split after the last delimiter to multiplication. source | Exercise indented/YAML continuation keys with multibyte prefixes; assert secret removal, harmless-prefix preservation and no panic. Current redactor evolved after snapshot. |
| S11 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:372:40: replace + with * in SecretRedactor::redact_line (log) |
G | Changes cursor advance after a vendor-prefix replacement; nonzero offsets can skip later candidates. source | Add two separated vendor tokens with nonzero first offset, then assert both redacted and operation terminates; map onto current scanner before rerun. |
| S12 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:416:45: replace \|\| with && in SecretRedactor::redact_value_span (log) |
G | Quoted-value scanning can stop at the wrong boundary when quote alternatives become conjunctive. source | Add both quote styles with trailing public fields, escaped quotes and unterminated values; verify redaction plus preserved boundaries. |
| S13 | Timeout: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:563:40: replace + with * in SecretRedactor::redact_colon_assignments (log) |
T | Skipped colon syntax no longer advances when colon_idx is zero: zero*1 stays zero. Log records tests running >60s then Timeout. source | For a frozen input beginning with a skipped colon, source shows a no-progress loop in the mutant. Keep Timeout; add bounded direct regression if rerunning, not Caught. |
| S14 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:620:51: replace - with + in SecretRedactor::redact_cli_flags (log) |
G | CLI flag boundary checks the following byte instead of preceding byte. source | Test alphanumeric-prefixed --secret false positives and valid standalone flags; current redactor must be targeted separately. |
| S15 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:803:78: replace == with != in SecretRedactor::redact_jwt_tokens (log) |
G | JWT token alphabet changes hyphen equality to inequality, widening scans across delimiters and excluding hyphens. source | Test base64url segments containing hyphens plus punctuation/quotes after complete JWTs; assert exact redacted span. |
| S16 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/redact.rs:937:13: replace \|\| with && in SecretRedactor::is_high_entropy_secret_candidate (log) |
G | Entropy exemption for dot-containing tokens can be weakened by a neighboring false predicate. source | Test dotted code/path literals and eligible entropy strings independently; broad fuzz success alone does not adjudicate this mutant. |
| S17 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-codec/src/skeleton.rs:228:45: replace < with <= in StructuralSkeletonizer::skeletonize_diff (log) |
G | Diff skeleton file limit changes from four to five. source | Add a five-distinct-file diff and assert the documented compact file-clause cap; lossy skeletons need a shape oracle, not exact-source recovery. |
| S18 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/lib.rs:406:76: replace && with \|\| in HdcAssociativeIndex::compute_subject_bloom32 (log) |
N | Changes subject tokenization and therefore approximate subject bloom ranking. source | No universal heuristic-recall oracle establishes a production defect. Add path/colon/underscore token fixtures and benchmark quality/cost before deciding whether exact tokenization is a contract. |
| S19 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/lib.rs:638:13: replace \|\| with && in HdcAssociativeIndex::query_associative (log) |
N | Changes full-scan eligibility versus coarse candidate selection, especially legacy/no-postings paths. source | Candidate membership may change, not just cost. Exact lexical union remains separate; compare seeded old 03/current 04 corpora and tie order. No general equivalence or bug is established. |
| S20 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/fractal.rs:203:25: replace * with / in FractalCoord::morton_z64 (log) |
G | Positive coordinate binning divides by eight instead of multiplying. source | Directed run catches this exact mutant using literal Morton vectors; later negative-half vector addresses a different directed survivor. |
| S21 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/fractal.rs:248:24: replace ^ with & in FractalCoord::digest_u32 (log) |
G | FNV byte mixing becomes bitwise AND. source | Directed run catches this exact mutant; numeric_vectors_v120 includes literal expected digest. |
| S22 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/fractal.rs:388:23: replace \|\| with && in FractalTrajectoryArchive::query_shared_suffix (log) |
P | Removes an early return only when one of top_k==0 or empty collection is true. source | Source proof: empty iterator stays empty; otherwise truncate(0) returns empty. Nonempty/top_k>0 takes the same path. Returned values equivalent; zero-k work/allocation can increase. |
| S23 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/hv.rs:155:25: replace >> with << in Hypervector::from_u64_seed (log) |
G | Changes the SplitMix recurrence shift direction. source | Directed run catches exact mutant with independent literal seed words; retain original Missed. |
| S24 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/hv.rs:513:24: replace ^= with &= in Hypervector::sketch_256 (log) |
G | A zero-initialized sketch changes XOR accumulation to AND, collapsing sparse information. source | Directed run catches exact mutant with independent sparse rotating-sketch vector. |
| S25 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-hdc/src/surprise.rs:221:18: replace - with / in TitansSurpriseGate::observe_with_exit_code (log) |
G | Novelty 1-similarity becomes 1/similarity and then clamps; repeated-fingerprint tests can bypass this branch. source | Directed run still missed; current numeric_vectors_v120 adds a near vector with a new fingerprint and hand-calculated novelty. Later addition is not Caught evidence. |
| S26 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-bus/src/ring.rs:280:30: replace >> with << in unpack_meta (log) |
G | Surprise metadata unpacking shifts left, losing the encoded byte. source | Directed bus run catches exact mutant and all selected metadata shifts. |
| S27 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-bus/src/ring.rs:945:49: replace * with + in SeqlockTelemetryBus::poll_since (log) |
G | File-backed sketch channel slice offset uses addition instead of eight-byte stride. source | Directed bus run catches exact mutant; file-backed patterned channels are required, not only in-process publish tests. |
| S28 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/antigravity.rs:424:41: delete ! in AntigravityAdapter::handle_hook (log) |
G | Subagent summary filter accepts empty summaries and rejects nonempty summaries. source | Test missing/empty/nonempty Antigravity completion summaries and resulting fold content. |
| S29 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/hermes.rs:98:42: replace <= with > in HermesAdapter::sanitize_embedded_ahtl_line (log) |
G | Embedded AHTL takes fallback sanitization rather than delimiter-aware segment handling. source | Test valid embedded packets with secrets in individual fields and oversized input; require packet/framing and redaction invariants, not merely no secret output. |
| S30 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/mmu.rs:200:25: replace -= with /= in InfinityContextMmu::extract_hook_subject (log) |
G | UTF-8 subject prefix retreat divides rather than decrements; can shorten subject to byte zero. source | Use a command crossing byte 48 inside a multibyte codepoint; assert maximal safe prefix and stable hash, not just valid UTF-8. |
| S31 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/mmu.rs:314:40: replace != with == in InfinityContextMmu::truncate_agent_suffix (log) |
G | Suffix truncation retains the wrong agent occurrences. source | Interleave two agents then rewind one; assert only that agent suffix is removed and replay identity is retained. |
| S32 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/mmu.rs:377:25: replace == with != in InfinityContextMmu::ingest_or_reuse_at_index (log) |
G | Exit-code replay identity uses inequality, allowing reuse/re-ingest decisions to invert. source | Replay same occurrence with changed exit code and observe new verdict/state; separately assert unchanged event reuse. |
| S33 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/mmu.rs:897:47: delete ! in InfinityContextMmu::build_ephemeral_tail_slot_inner (log) |
G | Deletes negation in punctuation trim; alphanumeric content can be trimmed away. source | Independent punctuated-query mutated-source regression exits 101 as expected (tail-ppr-mutant.json). This later focused rejection does not change sampled Missed. |
| S34 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-adapters/src/workspace.rs:172:5: replace require_absolute -> Result<(), TrustError> with Ok(()) (log) |
G | Private workspace absolute-path guard is removed. source | Exercise public workspace setup with relative HOME/XDG roots in an isolated environment; assert failure before creating state. Tests using only absolute temp paths cannot reject this mutant. |
| S35 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:1039:24: delete ! in WireProxyTransformer::transform_sse_line_stateful (log) |
G | SSE template capture can select the wrong pending stream state. source | Interleave pending tool streams with delayed template arrivals; assert both identifiers and emitted buffered data. Single-stream round-trip is insufficient. |
| S36 | Timeout: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:1216:9: replace WireProxyTransformer::strip_provider_route_prefix -> String with String::new() (log) |
T | Route rewriting becomes an empty path; log shows the proxy monolithic test >60s then Timeout. source | Malformed/empty upstream route can strand an integration exchange. Add a direct route-prefix input/output test plus bounded mock transport; do not infer exact hang cause solely from timeout. |
| S37 | Timeout: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:1293:38: replace == with != in WireProxyTransformer::read_next_http_chunk (log) |
T | Trailer blank-line terminator equality becomes inequality; log shows proxy test timeout. source | Exercise empty and nonempty trailers and EOF with a bounded reader; outcome remains unresolved timeout, not semantic-equivalence evidence. |
| S38 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:1500:57: replace \|\| with && in WireProxyTransformer::relay_upstream_response_with_eof (log) |
G | HEAD/204/304 bodyless-response alternatives become conjunctive around one status check. source | Assert HEAD, 204 and 304 independently against a mock upstream that supplies no body and clean EOF; protect status/header handling. |
| S39 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:2222:21: replace && with \|\| in WireProxyTransformer::handle_http_request_concurrent (log) |
G | Transfer-Encoding classification accepts unrelated headers or non-chunked values. source | Test unrelated header containing chunked, TE identity, valid mixed-case TE chunked, and framing conflicts; assert request consumption/rejection. |
| S40 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-proxy/src/wire.rs:2744:26: replace += with *= in WireProxyTransformer::virtualize_item_text (log) |
G | Proxy occurrence index multiplies rather than increments; repeated item identities can collapse. source | Transform multiple tool items and replay/rewind; assert distinct ordered occurrence identities, CAS retention and stable output. |
| S41 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:369:36: replace < with <= in run_daemon (log) |
G | A terminal --idle-exit flag can pass bounds guard and index args[len]. source | Add missing-value CLI case and require normal diagnostic/nonzero exit rather than panic. Valid-value happy path does not exercise boundary. |
| S42 | Timeout: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:474:15: replace += with *= in parse_dir_flag (log) |
T | At first --dir index zero, i*=2 does not advance; CLI integration log ends in Timeout. source | Source establishes no-progress on leading --dir in the mutant; add subprocess deadline regression. Preserve Timeout instead of recording Caught. |
| S43 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:615:28: replace + with * in execute_hook (log) |
G | --event guard uses i*1 rather than i+1; a final flag can index beyond args. source | Test terminal/missing --event and normal --agent/--event permutations; require explicit error with no panic. |
| S44 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:834:33: replace match guard i + 1 < args.len() with true in run_proxy_server (log) |
G | --max-requests always passes value-availability guard. source | Test trailing --max-requests with no value using bounded subprocess and assert diagnostic, not panic. |
| S45 | Timeout: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:832:19: replace += with -= in run_proxy_server (log) |
T | Proxy-server --dir cursor decreases instead of increases; source can underflow at first index. Log records broader CLI test Timeout. source | Direct option-parser subprocess should reject/halt predictably. Arithmetic suggests panic for some positions, but recorded timeout cause is not established; no invented Caught result. |
| S46 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:913:35: replace + with - in execute_proxy_transform (log) |
G | Proxy-transform --dir uses preceding argument instead of next, or underflows at zero. source | Run --dir first and after provider selection; assert selected workspace and no out-of-bounds panic. |
| S47 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:1395:26: replace * with / in varied_tool_log_fixture (log) |
N | Changes synthetic varied-log word schedule; this is fixture content, not an algorithm correctness oracle. source | No runtime defect follows from a different deterministic fixture. Preserve fixture provenance/digest and requalify reported measurements if changed; do not call it equivalent benchmark input. |
| S48 | MissedMutant: crates/icx-cli/src/main.rs:1560:48: replace * with / in run_benchmark (log) |
G | PPR elapsed seconds divided instead of multiplied by 1e6; reported microseconds/SLO checks can be corrupted. source | Assert benchmark report units with independently injected elapsed duration or parser/oracle; shape-only report tests are insufficient. |
The table preserves the recorded 43 MissedMutant and five Timeout outcomes. Source reasoning establishes two narrow returned-value-equivalent fast paths (S08/S22); three heuristic/fixture rows remain N (S18/S19/S47). The remaining survivors have concrete oracle follow-ups. This classification does not relabel historical outcomes as passed.
Directed critical survivors¶
All 29 directed misses are listed here, including the three already listed above; overlap labels prevent treating them as new independent gaps. The directed outcomes also retain all 30 caught names. In particular, later directed experiments reject the sampled turn-cache fallback, positive Morton binning, digest/sketch/seed arithmetic, both selected bus families, Profile A hex parser guards, and the relocated frame-fit selection guard. Those are distinct recorded observations, not changes to the earlier sample.
| ID | Full recorded semantic name | Class | Source guard / evidence and follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| D01 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:529:17: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| verified_chunks.contains_key(&cid). Chunk digest/ID/duplicate guards: forge each independently, including valid digest with wrong short ID, wrong full digest, and duplicate entries. source |
| D02 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:528:17: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| computed_digest != cdigest. Chunk digest/ID/duplicate guards: forge each independently, including valid digest with wrong short ID, wrong full digest, and duplicate entries. source |
| D03 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:541:17: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| store.artifacts.contains_key(&id). Artifact digest-prefix/line-count/duplicate guards: test each malformed field and duplicate artifact independently. source |
| D04 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:540:17: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| art.chunk_ids.len() != art.line_index.len(). Artifact digest-prefix/line-count/duplicate guards: test each malformed field and duplicate artifact independently. source |
| D05 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:552:50: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: if computed_bytes != art.total_bytes \|\| computed_bytes > ICX_MAX_INGEST_BYTES {. Test wrong declared total bytes separately from over-limit computed size; max-size allocation test needs an explicit resource bound. source |
| D06 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:568:21: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| entry.end_line != end_line. Single start_line/end_line corruption; current integrity_v120 now includes both. No post-addition directed rerun is recorded here. source |
| D07 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:567:21: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| entry.start_line != start_line. Single start_line/end_line corruption; current integrity_v120 now includes both. No post-addition directed rerun is recorded here. source |
| D08 | crates/icx-core/src/cas.rs:583:17: replace \|\| with && in CasStore::from_parts |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| art.total_lines != expected_total_lines. Test wrong total_lines independently from wrong full digest; current five line-entry tests do not by themselves cover total_lines. source |
| D09 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:976:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| *node_id != id. Turn digest-prefix/internal-ID/map-key checks: current integrity_v120 adds isolated data and jointly forged map/internal IDs; rerun each guard. Already S05 above; same recorded name. source |
| D10 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:975:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| ArtifactId::from_digest(&recomputed) != *node_id. Turn digest-prefix/internal-ID/map-key checks: current integrity_v120 adds isolated data and jointly forged map/internal IDs; rerun each guard. source |
| D11 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:987:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| tool.id != id. ToolArtifact digest, internal ID and map-key checks need independent serde-restored corruptions; turn/epoch-only tests do not prove coverage. source |
| D12 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:986:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| ArtifactId::from_digest(&recomputed) != tool.id. ToolArtifact digest, internal ID and map-key checks need independent serde-restored corruptions; turn/epoch-only tests do not prove coverage. source |
| D13 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1006:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| folded_ahtl_commit.len() < expected_prefix.len() + expected_suffix.len(). SubTrajectoryBranch prefix/suffix/minimum-length checks: independent malformed frame cases; correlated framing failures must not mask each other. source |
| D14 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1005:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| !folded_ahtl_commit.ends_with(&expected_suffix). SubTrajectoryBranch prefix/suffix/minimum-length checks: independent malformed frame cases; correlated framing failures must not mask each other. source |
| D15 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1036:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| *raw_tokens_saved != expected_saved. Branch digest-prefix/map key/raw_tokens_saved checks: corrupt each separately while preserving child integrity and canonical fold framing. source |
| D16 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1035:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| *node_id != id. Branch digest-prefix/map key/raw_tokens_saved checks: corrupt each separately while preserving child integrity and canonical fold framing. source |
| D17 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1034:21: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| ArtifactId::from_digest(&recomputed) != *node_id. Branch digest-prefix/map key/raw_tokens_saved checks: corrupt each separately while preserving child integrity and canonical fold framing. source |
| D18 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1075:29: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| !frame_matches(. Folded L4 epoch index/root/ID/map-key/raw-token/frame checks: independently corrupt each serde-restored field and verify rejection. source |
| D19 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1074:29: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| exp_raw != *raw_tokens. Folded L4 epoch index/root/ID/map-key/raw-token/frame checks: independently corrupt each serde-restored field and verify rejection. source |
| D20 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1073:29: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| *node_id != id. Folded L4 epoch index/root/ID/map-key/raw-token/frame checks: independently corrupt each serde-restored field and verify rejection. source |
| D21 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1072:29: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| exp_id != *node_id. Folded L4 epoch index/root/ID/map-key/raw-token/frame checks: independently corrupt each serde-restored field and verify rejection. source |
| D22 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1071:29: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| exp_root != *merkle_root. Folded L4 epoch index/root/ID/map-key/raw-token/frame checks: independently corrupt each serde-restored field and verify rejection. source |
| D23 | crates/icx-core/src/dag.rs:1112:25: replace \|\| with && in MerkleContextDag::verify_merkle_integrity_with_ancestors |
G | Frozen guard token: \|\| *node_id != id. L3 epoch digest-prefix/map-key/frame checks; current map/internal-ID and root tests added after the snapshot. Rerun independently. Already S06 above; same recorded name. source |
| D24 | crates/icx-core/src/epoch.rs:444:51: replace <= with > in CacheEpochController::assemble_window |
G | Frozen guard token: let pinned_head = if diagnostic.len() <= cap {. Oversized-head fallback diagnostic-fit guard, not whole-frame fit. Test cap below diagnostic length and cap exactly diagnostic length; assert managed view stays within cap. source |
| D25 | crates/icx-hdc/src/fractal.rs:205:29: replace * with / in FractalCoord::morton_z64 |
G | Frozen guard token: (((c + 1.0) * 8.0).floor() as u64).min(7). Negative coordinate binning at -0.5 differs between multiply/divide; current numeric_vectors_v120 adds literal 0x0000ffff00000000. Added after this frozen run, not counted caught. source |
| D26 | crates/icx-hdc/src/surprise.rs:221:18: replace - with / in TitansSurpriseGate::observe_with_exit_code |
G | Frozen guard token: (1.0 - self.bundler.finalize().similarity(hv)).clamp(0.0, 1.0). Near-vector/new-fingerprint novelty arithmetic remains missed in directed snapshot; current hand-calculated third observation was added later, not counted caught. Already S25 above; same recorded name. source |
| D27 | crates/icx-codec/src/ahtl.rs:623:33: replace \|\| with && in AhtlPacket::to_profile_a |
G | Frozen guard token: if fc_clean.len() != 64 \|\| !fc_clean.bytes().all(\|b\| b.is_ascii_hexdigit()) {. Promotion length and alphabet are independent malformed fc/hv cases. Current codec_v120 promotion test adds both for each field after this snapshot; not a recorded rejection yet. source |
| D28 | crates/icx-codec/src/ahtl.rs:630:33: replace \|\| with && in AhtlPacket::to_profile_a |
G | Frozen guard token: if hv_clean.len() != 16 \|\| !hv_clean.bytes().all(\|b\| b.is_ascii_hexdigit()) {. Promotion length and alphabet are independent malformed fc/hv cases. Current codec_v120 promotion test adds both for each field after this snapshot; not a recorded rejection yet. source |
| D29 | crates/icx-codec/src/ahtl.rs:861:46: replace \|\| with && in EpochHeader::parse |
G | Frozen guard token: if !(4..=8).contains(&ep_part.len()) \|\| !ep_part.bytes().all(\|b\| b.is_ascii_hexdigit()) {. Epoch-header ep width 4..8 and hex alphabet guard. from_str_radix separately rejects invalid hex, but valid 1–3-digit epochs can bypass width under this mutation. Add short valid-hex and 9-digit cases; not equivalent. source |
Current follow-up evidence and remaining limits¶
Core integrity tests now cover all five CAS line-entry fields, deduplicated chunk count, fallback turn lookup, digest tampering and self-consistent forged Turn/CacheEpoch map/internal IDs that disagree with the computed digest prefix. They do not establish every ToolArtifact, branch, folded-epoch, duplicate-entry, total-lines or maximum-size guard mutation is caught. Correlated corruption can trigger an unchanged neighboring guard, so independent field cases matter.
HDC numeric vectors now include negative Morton half-space and near/new-fingerprint novelty cases; codec tests independently test promotion length/alphabet. These latest additions occurred after the directed source snapshot. This document records their existence and intended oracle, not an unrecorded successful mutation rerun. The isolated PPR trim experiment does record a focused later test rejection (expected exit 101); it overlaps S33 and adds no new unique sample count.
The redactor source changed further after these frozen runs while fuzz findings were repaired and original regressions replayed. Frozen redactor locations must be remapped onto the current scanner before further mutation experiments. Passing those later original-code regressions is counterevidence against specific reproduced fuzz failures, not proof that the old redactor survivors are now caught or equivalent. See retained fuzz outcomes and the release qualification record for the latest completed campaign; unfinished/interrupted campaigns remain distinct.
No concrete defect in the unmutated current source was established by this read-only review. No material branch was proven unreachable in the original program; the two P rows describe redundant early-return work, not unreachable public functionality. The observable mutation gaps above remain follow-up work, especially independent integrity checks, noncanonical header widths, CLI missing-value boundaries, and HTTP framing/SSE cases. The original 5,226-entry full mutation space remains unexecuted; later inventory changes do not establish exhaustive coverage. Closing an audit/release ticket must preserve these limits rather than assert exhaustive mutation resistance or convert test additions into historical caught counts.
Later executed evidence¶
The following separate frozen rechecks supersede statements above that these particular follow-up oracles had not yet been mutation-tested. They preserve every original table and outcome:
- r2: HDC 13/13 caught, including negative Morton and near-vector novelty; codec 6/6 caught, including promotion length/alphabet and EpochHeader widths. Core recorded 11 caught / 19 missed from 30 selected.
- r3: later independent CAS metadata tests changed the core recheck to 16 caught / 14 missed from the same 30 selected semantic families.
- r4: independent chunk ID/full-digest and ToolArtifact/L2/L4 map-ID, content, framing and token-field corruption oracles produced 29 caught / 1 missed from 30 selected. See its adjudication. The remaining miss was the oversized-head diagnostic-fit comparison.
- r5: a public-constructor test requires an actionable
ICX_CONTEXT_BUDGET_EXCEEDEDdiagnostic for an oversized pinned head. A bounded two-caseassemble_windowrecheck caught both the diagnostic-fit mutation and the frame-allowance mutation. This is later proof for the r4 survivor, not a revision of r4's outcome.
The original directed bus run remains 10/10 caught in the 59-case record. These follow-ups overlap each other and earlier samples; no additional aggregate unique coverage count is asserted. Each linked run retains its own source manifest, full per-crate inventory, selector and outcomes. The directly rechecked critical families are now caught by the described oracles. The broad sample's 43 historical misses remain recorded misses; unrelated oracle gaps, heuristic cases, timeouts and unexecuted mutation space remain subject to their original limits. No exhaustive mutation-resistance claim follows from these bounded rechecks.