Independent reassessment of all prior findings¶
The old CSV has 51 entries, not 55: reserved 029 and 043–045 were merged. This table covers every actual row. “Fixed” is scoped to the original failure and cited mechanism, not certification of an entire subsystem. No prior private exploit evidence or live repository settings were assumed available.
| Prior ID | Previous reported state | Independent disposition and evidence |
|---|---|---|
| ICX-AUD-001 | fixed | Partially verified remediation; broader latency claims require scale tests: Source persists HDC snapshots and ships daemon. This component benchmark does not prove 10k real-binary hook p99. |
| ICX-AUD-002 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for labeling; fixture-dependent effectiveness remains unverified: CLI/docs now call the number byte proxy; provider response-token measurements not performed. |
| ICX-AUD-003 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for identified placement/stripping defects: Content-block insertion, preservation/count of client breakpoints and TTL ordering logic; original broad prefix-rewrite allegation was overstated. Provider hit effectiveness remains unverified. |
| ICX-AUD-004 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for inspected event fields: Shape-aware Bash object, PreCompact stdout, proper stop input; source and public docs. Every generic tool schema has not been exercised live. |
| ICX-AUD-005 | partial | Partially fixed: Built-in duplicate context removed and configuration docs corrected; unsupported MCP replacement persists (035), rollout zstd/CLI wiring absent. |
| ICX-AUD-006 | partial | Partially fixed: Invalid ready-to-run shim claims removed, absence of Python integration disclosed; no shim ships. |
| ICX-AUD-007 | fixed | Partially fixed: Stop/budget override repaired, named config locations corrected; undocumented UI-hidden behavior remains unverified. |
| ICX-AUD-008 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for original version-negotiation defect; new envelope validation issue 031 is separate Partially fixed: Legacy negotiation and modern discovery added; malformed input validation still incomplete (031). |
| ICX-AUD-009 | fixed | Confirmed fixed: PreToolUse no longer echoes output-only permission fields for Claude/Codex. |
| ICX-AUD-010 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for default CLI trust path: workspace::resolve, prepare, verify, owner/store seals; repository .icx is not selected implicitly. Existing trust tests exercise replacement and modified rows. |
| ICX-AUD-011 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for prefix-marker bypass: Exact emitted-block digest membership plus Tier-0 escaping replaces prefix-based trust. This cannot prevent natural-language prompt injection; that limitation is documented. |
| ICX-AUD-012 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for default CLI route: Token check on all routes, loopback bind restriction in CLI; opt-out flags explicitly weaken controls. |
| ICX-AUD-013 | fixed | Confirmed fixed: Private directory/file creation and .gitignore rewrite; adoption tightens owned regular files. |
| ICX-AUD-014 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for original unbounded stdin defect; elapsed-time/concurrency limits remain separate hardening Partially fixed / bounded: CLI hook/MCP bounds and fold depth exist. Single-request limits are not a complete concurrency or elapsed-time budget. |
| ICX-AUD-015 | fixed | Partially fixed: URL/vendor/next-line fixtures added; YAML block scalars fail (001) |
| ICX-AUD-016 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for reported inline-PEM bug: Inline spans replace start..end and continue; runaway bounds remain documented |
| ICX-AUD-017 | fixed | Partially fixed: Current threat model now names implemented controls and residual risks. Its blanket guarantees require the qualifications above and the bus/integration reports. |
| ICX-AUD-018 | fixed | Confirmed fixed in source/tests: Nonblocking no-follow transcript open plus regular-file check. |
| ICX-AUD-019 | fixed | Confirmed fixed: File descriptor flags, fstat ownership/regular-file/mode checks are present. Metadata/path race freedom against same-user writers is outside scope. |
| ICX-AUD-020 | fixed | Partially fixed: Private scratch files, RAII cleanup and periodic/startup sweeps exist. SIGKILL residue persists until a sweep as documented. The additional continuous-stream cancellation lead 034 was rejected after real-curl countertesting. |
| ICX-AUD-021 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for secret-free full-byte storage: Independent four-fixture equality probe plus separate storage redact/presentation escaping paths; redaction itself is intentionally lossy. |
| ICX-AUD-022 | fixed | Partially fixed: MMU checked-to-unchecked fallback removed; documented unchecked/truncating public API remains. |
| ICX-AUD-023 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for silent overwrite: DAG collision guard and checked CAS insertion reject divergent digest/node identity. No practical 64-bit collision search was attempted. |
| ICX-AUD-024 | fixed | Confirmed fixed: Hex epoch formatting, 4–8 digit parser and DAG round-trip test |
| ICX-AUD-025 | fixed | Confirmed fixed at slice_hint: Invalid hints not rendered and rejected on parse; Profile A skeleton separate defect 002 |
| ICX-AUD-026 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for parser input: Iterative max 64 materialized links; no claim on arbitrary manually built/serde-recursive trees |
| ICX-AUD-027 | fixed | Confirmed fixed in source: Spread high-bit masks and non-single-chunk fixture exist. Independent repository-wide deduplication benchmark was not repeated here. Confirmed fixed for varied CDC fixture: Current CAS fixture uses deterministic varied lines and reports chunk count. |
| ICX-AUD-028 | fixed | Substantially fixed, remaining extrapolation caveat: Native flags recorded, portable/native repeats measured here; ICX-CODEX-072. |
| ICX-AUD-030 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for stale Chapter 08 struct: PDF now has current fields and six-way split |
| ICX-AUD-031 | fixed | Partially fixed: Q1.14/Q15 mismatch 005; current core spec improved but AHTL chapters remain stale |
| ICX-AUD-032 | partial | Partially fixed via supplement: Historical exactness review unchanged; corrections file supplies arithmetic and provenance caveats |
| ICX-AUD-033 | fixed | Partially fixed: Dated corrections identify ACM/LCM/RVQ attribution issues; current accepted ADR-0003 still repeats misattributed cost/TTFT and provider-hit assertions (100). All 22 arXiv IDs resolve, not every paper claim reproduced. |
| ICX-AUD-034 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for explicit Cargo/REUSE crate declarations; no legal certification: Adapters/proxy manifests now specify GPL AND AGPL; first-party root GPL, notices and license texts inspected. Combined-work interpretation remains counsel scope. |
| ICX-AUD-035 | deferred | Open/deferred: ICX-CODEX-074; same unresolved terms persist. |
| ICX-AUD-036 | partial | Partially fixed: REUSE now separately labels Zep NC-SA and remaining arXiv PDFs; non-exclusive papers are link-only in index. Unicode issue persists; no complete license attestation for every embedded image. |
| ICX-AUD-037 | partial | Partially fixed / live settings unverifiable: SECURITY.md now provides private reporting URL and response target. Required-check and signatures-branch protection not inferred from YAML. |
| ICX-AUD-038 | partial | Partially fixed: Asset input directory is configurable; patents ignored in tracked rules; history and binary duplication remain. No claim all historical personal paths are purged. |
| ICX-AUD-039 | partial | Partially fixed: Properties/fuzz targets exist; Profile A hostile fields and YAML scalar syntax absent from shown tests Partially fixed: Property tests/fuzz exist; new mutation survivors remain, ICX-CODEX-073. |
| ICX-AUD-040 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for original SHA/toolchain/policy issues; release CI-success gap 070 is separate Pins and deny policy fixed; no complete CI success predicate in release: Supply-chain report ICX-CODEX-070. Confirmed fixed for enumerated pins/policy; doctor partial: Full SHA pins, exact toolchain/tools and deny policy verified. Doctor on uninitialized CI state remains shallow; release ancestry defect newly identified. |
| ICX-AUD-041 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for reported unused dependencies: Old proxy codec/serde removed; CLI serde is now Unix-only and used by daemon. cargo-machete result in gate evidence. |
| ICX-AUD-042 | fixed | Confirmed fixed for duplicate results: Ranked hits dedup by ArtifactId; candidate-crowding lead remains unverified Confirmed fixed in source: Tail candidates deduplicate artifact IDs; scale/recall quality belongs to report 02. |
| ICX-AUD-046 | fixed | Partially fixed: Main bus documentation now describes file I/O and writer locks accurately; stale module/API titles and diagram/ADR language survive (see report 08). |
| ICX-AUD-047 | fixed | Partially fixed: Single transaction repairs multi-file atomicity; sealed MAC repairs untrusted derived state for CLI. Unsealed/legacy DAG load remains less validated; daemon acknowledgment durability is ICX-CODEX-030. |
| ICX-AUD-048 | fixed | Unverifiable in graph alone: Adapter clock mode determines timestamps; graph itself accepts caller times Confirmed fixed as documented opt-in: use_wall_clock and monotonic clock implementation; deterministic library default remains intentional. |
| ICX-AUD-049 | fixed | Partially fixed: Repetitive success, varied-corpus collapse 004 Separate mathematical/retrieval report owns reassessment: Component target query is planted and cannot alone demonstrate general recall. |
| ICX-AUD-050 | fixed | Partially fixed: i32 removes demonstrated i16 saturation; encoding CPU profile not independently refreshed Source remediation visible; measured implementation parity is separate: No assertion that one microbenchmark proves saturation behavior. |
| ICX-AUD-051 | fixed | Partially fixed in prose: Current subsystem spec says inspired; historical and AHTL prose still contains stronger claims |
| ICX-AUD-052 | open | Open limitation, partly mitigated: Inverse check rejects opposite orthants, cannot prove original-event suffix identity |
| ICX-AUD-053 | fixed | Confirmed fixed as disclosure: hv64 linear collision warning present; no claim hash itself became collision resistant |
| ICX-AUD-054 | fixed | Partially fixed: Typed publish failures and loss counters exist; expected sequence invariant still missing (ICX-CODEX-032). The MMU uses ordinary workspace-filtered polling, not a complete loss-repair protocol. |
| ICX-AUD-055 | fixed | Partially fixed: Existing test uses two handles in one process. This audit adds a real two-process measurement; it does not demonstrate all four real harnesses or establish their p99 propagation bound. Partially verified: Two-handle same-process test is distinct from four OS processes/agents; no four-agent timing established here. |
No new issue is labeled regressed without comparative old-revision reproduction. Current counterexamples can instead demonstrate a residual or broader coverage gap.