Skip to content

Coverage ledger and verification limits

Baseline and file accounting

The baseline contains 519 tracked paths, including 103 Markdown files. Each path has its byte size, SHA-256, assigned workstream and disposition/depth in inventory.csv. The baseline revision, branch transition and preserved AGENTS content hash are in baseline.json. The initial only tracked change was AGENTS.md:24 insertions and 1 deletion. Audit-created files are separately confined to docs/codex/; no pre-existing untracked project content was found before their creation.

The path inventory is exhaustive for tracked files. Semantic assurance is not uniform or exhaustive. A hashed asset is accounted for, not proven correct. An executed test is not the same as reviewing its oracle. Historical HTML/JSON/Wikimedia/ISO archives were inventoried and sampled for relevant claims/provenance; all their embedded external pages were not rereviewed. Ignored build trees and private/local state are outside the source inventory. No user memory, credential database, or active agent configuration was changed.

Workstream coverage

Area Reviewed/executed Exact depth / remaining limitation
icx-core CAS/chunker/DAG/epoch source, baseline tests, mutation partitions; byte and epoch probes State source review targeted by mechanism; not every in-module test independently inspected. Epoch assembly/defaults independently rechecked by root
icx-codec Production parser/renderer, redactor, skeletonizer and Braille paths; property/regression tests and fuzz Codec per-file ledger; some long fixture tails sampled. Profile A framing and YAML secrets independently reproduced
icx-hdc Index/query/snapshot/bundler/fractal/surprise source; algebra derivations; 27 scaling datasets; fuzz/mutation Three seeds, 100/1k/10k repetitive/varied/multilingual corpora. Live-model retrieval effectiveness remains outside offline evidence
icx-store Functional edges, temporal query, CSR and PPR source; baseline tests and independent dense numerical oracle Oracle is a small three-node vector; no realistic multi-hop graph contribution ablation. Transaction-time query axis not demonstrated
icx-bus Layout/attach/publish/poll/loss source; stress/regression tests; corrupted metadata, truncation and separate-process probes No exhaustive weak-memory proof, all interleavings, sequence wrap, four live harnesses or every process-death point
icx-adapters Workspace trust, seals, SQLite, MMU selected paths; all adapter wire contracts; MCP fuzz/probes State per-file CSV. Complete text reads for selected modules, targeted source for others. Live agents, every tool output shape and installed Hermes shim not exercised
icx-proxy Authentication/routing/framing/SSE/curl/caching source and baseline fixtures No exhaustive malformed HTTP/SSE campaign. A real-curl cancellation countertest rejects one source-only lead; no paid provider use
icx-cli Dispatch/workspace/deref/daemon/benchmark/doctor paths; binary tests; real CLI YAML roundtrip CLI tests rerun with socket permission. Doctor detects installations, not live tool interception. Daemon ACK/final-failure probes use actual daemon module with synthetic dispatcher
AHTL PDF Hash; all 58 pages extracted and assigned chapter; conformance matrix; root contact-sheet layout pass of all 58 Two equation/code pages checked at full size. Contact-sheet thumbnails do not certify every equation/table cell; model-effectiveness statements were not validated
docs/ and root prose Quantitative/normative lead extraction, architecture/interfaces/data-model/security/build/testing/deployment, accepted ADRs and prior reports Current core documents reviewed across workers; some historical reports and large tables targeted/sampled. Claims grouped by material mechanism in report 08, not 826 independent verified assertions
ref-docs/ prose Initial/research/corrections/prior-art/novel-methods/exactness/foundations, forensic ledger and Braille/BLAKE3 archives 22 arXiv identity checks plus selected primary-paper mechanisms. Every bibliography link/result and every archival proof not independently validated. Immutable references preserved
Roadmap and planning Roadmap, all phase/sprint files and implementation plans read as historical planning claims Completed checkboxes are not test evidence; stale current-version and success guarantees recorded as 100
Unicode tables All 256 detailed Braille table rows independently checked for codepoint/UTF-8/name/bit arithmetic Worked literal example separately fails 102; historical ISO adoption statements not fully rederived
Workflows/scripts/governance Semantic static review, self-tests, actionlint, dependency/notice/REUSE/secret checks GitHub live required-check policy, signing keys, legal grants for every embedded image and patent filing status not verified
Generated images/assets Full path/size/hash accounting and source-label/metadata sampling Not regenerated over source; no exhaustive visual or creator-rights certification. Source labels can be stale even when bitmap matches generator

Planned validation and excluded assurance

Requested validation Evidence disposition
Baseline format/Clippy/tests/rustdoc/95% coverage Executed; see report 06 and individual logs. Sandbox socket failures were separated from successful host reruns
Benchmark / doctor / dependency / notices / REUSE / secrets / workflow tests Executed with exact exits. Strict timing gates failed during contention; do not call all gates green. Installed vs CI secret scanner version differences adjudicated separately
Four existing fuzz targets, 15 minutes each Each has a900-second execution budget after build; final outcome records are in validation evidence. Requested duration alone is not proof a fuzzer completed
Mutation analysis across 8 crates Full mutant inventories; deterministic sampled partitions per crate. Full generated mutation space is not exhausted; survivors, unviable cases and timeouts remain distinct
100/1k/10k corpora, 3 seeds, varied/repetitive/multilingual Executed with lexical and exhaustive composite baselines, latency and serialized index sizes; multilingual RSS includes entire harness process
Ten independent portable/native benchmark repetitions and warm-up Executed; shared active-host contention limits timing inference. No small speedup or portable-SLO guarantee inferred
Byte recovery / corruption / crash / failed save Specific probes executed. Full power-cut, disk-full, competing-writer, fsync fault and every SQLite/slot transition matrix remains unexecuted
Agent/provider/tokenization behavior Public contract/source checks only. No live agent sessions, provider-cache counters, tokenizer APIs or reasoning-efficacy evaluation
Unsupported platforms No macOS/Windows/BSD or cross-architecture executable validation in this audit

These are practical coverage boundaries, not evidence that the excluded cases pass. The audit does not certify exhaustive source review, all platform support, formal algorithm correctness, legal compliance or absence of vulnerabilities. Its reproducible findings and explicit dispositions are intended to make the remaining work reviewable.